As the European Union (EU) moves toward the implementation of the Markets in Crypto-Assets (MiCA) regulation, the European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA) has adopted a pragmatic and forward-thinking approach to crypto regulation. In the latest episode of the MiCA Masters series on DACOM Digital, Will Marshall, Policy Officer at ESMA, shed light on the authority's role in ensuring a safe, regulated, and transparent environment for crypto asset markets. This blog explores highlights from the podcast, including ESMA's balanced view of the risks and innovations in crypto, how traditional finance regulation informs its view on which guidelines should apply to crypto markets, and the critical steps being taken to ensure supervisory convergence across EU jurisdictions.
Balancing Risk and Innovation in the Crypto Market
Crypto markets have long been seen as a high-risk space, rife with fraud and scams due to the absence of regulatory oversight. However, rather than taking a stance of skepticism, ESMA is approaching the regulation of crypto assets pragmatically. As Marshall explained, “If people are going to invest and trade in these assets, let’s make sure that it happens on a level playing field with traditional finance and that investors can do so safe from fraud and scams.”
This balanced approach reflects ESMA’s focus on protecting investors, maintaining market integrity and financial stability, without stifling the innovative potential that crypto assets and blockchain technology bring to the financial landscape. The goal is to ensure that crypto markets operate with the same level of security and protection as traditional financial markets, while also fostering innovation through effective regulation.
Preparing for Day One: MiCA’s Operational Readiness
MiCA is one of the world’s first comprehensive legal frameworks for crypto assets, putting the EU at the forefront of global crypto regulation. Its implementation will bring much-needed clarity to the market.
ESMA’s primary focus is to ensure that the MiCA regulatory framework is fully operational from day one. Marshall emphasized the importance of providing national supervisors and market participants with the legal clarity they need to operate effectively in the newly regulated crypto world. “Our focus is making sure that the MiCA regime is operational from day one,” Marshall explained, stressing the urgency for clear and consistent standards across the EU.
Validators, Miners, and Block-Building Entities: Clarifying Their Role
A significant topic discussed during the podcast was the potential classification of validators, miners, and other block-building entities as "persons professionally arranging and executing transactions" (PPAETs) under MiCA. This designation would impose specific obligations on these entities, such as monitoring and reporting market abuse. However, as Marshall pointed out, the crypto industry considers that validators and miners primarily serve a technical or operational function, focusing on network integrity and security rather than ‘arranging’ transactions as we understand the concept for financial intermediaries.
During the consultation process, market feedback strongly opposed the idea of classifying validators and miners as PPAETs given their technical role in blockchain consensus. “Stakeholders argued that these entities don’t really have decision-making authority over the transactions they process,” Marshall explained. Further, respondents to the consultation also argued that many of these entities lack the infrastructure and expertise to meet the reporting obligations required of entities in scope of MiCA. ESMA has acknowledged this feedback, and the final guidelines on this matter are expected later this year.
Ensuring Supervisory Convergence Across EU Jurisdictions
One of ESMA’s core responsibilities under MiCA is ensuring supervisory convergence across different EU jurisdictions. Since MiCA’s supervision and enforcement powers for crypto-asset service providers (CASPs) belongs to the National Competent Authorities (NCAs) of each member state, it is crucial to ensure that supervisory practices are consistent across the EU to avoid regulatory arbitrage.
Marshall highlighted that one of ESMA’s immediate priorities is making sure that supervisory practices are comparable across jurisdictions to ensure even application of the MiCA rulebook across CASPs operating in the EU. This would discourage CASPs from ‘forum-shopping’ whereby they seek authorizations in jurisdictions viewed as more favorable due to lenient enforcement.
The Role of NCAs in Effective Supervision
To facilitate supervisory convergence, Marshall emphasized the importance of preparations by NCAs’ staff who will be responsible for overseeing compliance with the MiCA market abuse obligations. Given the technical nature of crypto assets, one area that NCA staff may benefit from is additional training, especially as it relates to crypto-specific vectors for market abuse and the modern surveillance tools that enable effective detection and prevention of market abuse. Such training would be crucial to ensuring that NCAs can effectively assess whether CASPs are complying with MiCA’s standards and provide the oversight needed to protect investor trust and market integrity.
A Unified Approach to Crypto Regulation
As MiCA moves toward full implementation, ESMA will play a role in guiding and supporting NCAs to ensure that crypto markets are regulated consistently and fairly across the EU. Together with the NCAs supervising CASPs, ESMA aims to create a cohesive regulatory environment that provides a clear legal perimeter for the provision of crypto-asset services in the EU.
For CASPs, this means they can expect clear supervisory standards from NCAs and EU-level guidelines, ensuring they operate within a secure and transparent market environment. For regulators, the focus will be on building capacity through training, understanding the technical nuances of crypto, and ensuring that markets are properly supervised.
Conclusion
ESMA’s objective for the implementation of the MiCA framework is to set the stage for a secure, transparent, and innovative ecosystem for crypto asset services, balancing investor protection with the potential for dynamic market growth that innovations such as DLT can provide.
As MiCA nears full implementation, the focus on operational readiness, supervisory convergence, and the training of staff will be critical to creating a cohesive and well-regulated market environment. Whether you’re a CASP preparing for the new regulations or a regulator seeking to understand the evolving landscape, MiCA Masters is your ultimate resource for staying ahead of the curve in crypto compliance. Download our MiCA Factsheet for a clear overview of timelines, licensing requirements, and critical obligations. Or, tune in to the MiCA Masters Podcast series, where industry experts share insights, strategies, and best practices to help you navigate the EU’s regulatory landscape with confidence.
.png)
